The 2000s brought significant milestones for couples, from the adoption of domestic partner benefits by Durham city and county governments in the early 2000s to legalization of same-sex marriage in 2014.

In between was a roller-coaster ride, with a Durham couple bringing the first suit against the state for denying them a marriage license and North Carolinians deciding against gay marriage by voting for Amendment One, which put the issue of whether same-sex couples could marry on the ballot. Meanwhile, couples got married anyway in commitment ceremonies throughout the city. Gay-straight coalitions formed in schools, the first Beaver Queen Pageant was held, and the local music scene went nation wide with The Butchies, a queercore band.

Featured Topic

Amendment One

In May 2012, North Carolina voters approved Amendment One, an amendment to the North Carolina Constitution stating that “marriage between one man and one woman is the only domestic legal union that shall be valid or recognized in this state.” While state law already banned same-sex marriage, the amendment went one step further, denying recognition of any civil union, regardless of gender of the parties involved.

Politics + Activism, Family + Marriage, Audio + Video Clips

Amendment One

Anti-Amendment 1 poster designed by Allan Troxler. Allan Troxler Papers, LGBTQ Collection, North Carolina Collection, Durham County Library
Celebration of the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals ruling making same-sex marriage legal in North Carolina, at Parts & Labor at Motorco in Durham. Left to right: Sylvia Williams, wife of Helena Cragg; Helena Cragg, founding board chair of the LGBTQ Center of Durham; Tessa Thraves, partner of Milan Pham; Milan Pham, attorney for Chantelle and Marcie Fisher-Borne and a founding board member of LGBTQ Center of Durham; Marcie Fisher-Borne; Chantelle Fisher-Borne. Luke Hirst Papers, LGBTQ Collection, North Carolina Collection, Durham County Library
First same-sex couples to be legally married in Durham County, at the Register of Deeds office in the Durham County Administration Building. Luke Hirst Papers, LGBTQ Collection, North Carolina Collection, Durham County Library
View All of Us North Carolina: The Queer of Color Fight Against Amendment One. The film is a documentary by Sowjanya Kudva about an organization founded in Durham to defeat Amendment One and connect North Carolinians across a wide range of issues.

In May 2012, North Carolina voters approved Amendment One, an amendment to the North Carolina Constitution stating that “marriage between one man and one woman is the only domestic legal union that shall be valid or recognized in this state.” While state law already banned same-sex marriage, the amendment went one step further, denying recognition of any civil union, regardless of gender of the parties involved. However, 70% of Durham voters opposed the amendment, and Durham activists founded “All of Us NC” to oppose the amendment and work in the campaign against it.

In July 2014, the Fourth Circuit US Court of Appeals struck down Virginia’s same-sex marriage ban, setting a precedent for every state in the district, including North Carolina. In October 2014, the US District Court in Asheville declared Amendment One unconstitutional, allowing North Carolina same-sex couples to be legally married for the first time.

Durhamites Chantelle and Marcie Fisher-Borne were the lead plaintiffs in another lawsuit against Amendment One, this one filed by the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) of North Carolina to request the court’s recognition of same-sex couples’ rights to second-parent adoptions.